Which roofing material is best when it comes to quality and durability?

A leaky or damaged roof is not only unsafe for the home’s occupants, but it allows water to wreak havoc on attics, walls, ceilings, and more. A roof in good condition is critical to the overall quality of a home. With so many options on the market, it may be hard to know which roofing material is best. But have no fear; a few experts have answered this question for you.
Seth Larson

Seth Larson

Metal, Ceramic, or Asphalt

The best roofing material for durability is usually going to depend on where in the world you live; however, in most of the United States, that material is going to be metal.

Metal roofs can last well over 50 years if well-maintained. Commercial buildings often use them since they get set up when constructing the building, and you generally won’t have to worry about the roof again for the rest of your life.

Metal is very expensive as far as roofing options go, and it can sometimes be difficult to find a roofer who is able to install it for a residential home unless you’re living somewhere where snow is common.

Another great option for durability is clay or ceramic tile. The tiles themselves can often last a hundred years – in fact, there are buildings from as early as the 1800s with original roof tiles still intact and working as intended today.

Since tiles last so long, it’s easy to neglect other parts of your roof, such as underlayment. Underlayment generally needs to be replaced every 20 to 30 years under tile roofs in a process known as a tile relay. This means that your roofing tiles are removed and stored in a safe place, and then maintenance is done on the wood and underlayment. After this, the [roofers] reinstall the tiles.

Modern shingles are also an excellent option for durability. Shingles are the most popular option for roofing in the United States, as they are a good balance between durability, longevity, and affordability. They are not as durable as tile or metal [but] are also much cheaper to install. [If] properly installed, they are more cost-efficient in the long run, even though you will need to replace your shingles more often.

These Six Options Are Tops

    1. Metal Roofing: Metal roofs, [typically] made from steel, aluminum, copper, or zinc, are known for their long lifespan (up to 70 years in some cases) and durability. They are resistant to wind, fire, and impact damage. They’re also energy-efficient as they reflect sunlight rather than absorb heat.

    2. Slate: Slate roofing is incredibly durable, with a lifespan of up to 100 years or more if well-maintained. It’s also fire-resistant and performs well in a variety of climates. However, it’s among the most expensive roofing materials and requires specialized installation.

    3. Clay Or Concrete Tiles: Clay or concrete tiles are also very durable and can last several decades. They are especially good in hot climates or areas with a lot of sun exposure, as they’re highly resistant to heat. Like slate, they can be quite heavy and may require additional support, and they are also on the more expensive side.

    4. Architectural Asphalt Shingles: These are a more durable version of the typical asphalt shingle, with a thicker profile and a multi-dimensional appearance. They last longer than standard asphalt shingles (up to 30 years or more) and offer more resistance to wind and other weather conditions.

    5. Wood Shingles or Shakes: While not as long-lasting as other options, wood shingles or shakes can still last 30-40 years if properly maintained. They offer a natural, attractive appearance and some inherent insulation properties.

    6. Solar Tiles or Shingles: Increasingly popular, solar tiles or shingles provide the double function of serving as a roof covering and generating electricity. They’re typically made of durable materials, like tempered glass, and can last for several decades.

Brendan Anderson

Brendan Anderson

Founder of Brix Systems.
Austin Fain

Austin Fain


When it comes to quality and durability, there is no doubt that choosing the right roofing material can make all the difference. One of the most highly recommended options in this regard is metal roofing.

With its unmatched strength and resilience, metal roofs are designed to easily withstand harsh weather conditions such as heavy rain, hailstorms, strong winds, and extreme temperature changes. Unlike other materials that may rot or warp over time, metal boasts a long lifespan of up to 50 years or more with proper maintenance.

Additionally, metal roofing offers excellent energy efficiency by reflecting heat away from your home during hot summer months while retaining warmth inside during colder seasons – helping you save on energy costs over time.

Asphalt Shingles

Asphalt shingles stand out as the top choice for homeowners seeking optimal quality and durability in roofing materials. Asphalt shingles offer a range of benefits that make them a popular and reliable option.

First and foremost, they excel in longevity, typically lasting for 20 to 30 years or even more with proper maintenance. This durability is crucial in withstanding the elements, such as extreme weather conditions and temperature fluctuations.

Additionally, asphalt shingles boast excellent resistance against fire, which is a key factor in ensuring the safety of residential properties. They are also highly versatile, coming in various styles, colors, and textures to suit different architectural preferences and enhance curb appeal. This versatility allows homeowners to achieve the desired aesthetic while benefiting from the material’s long-lasting performance.

Ben Gold

This is a crowdsourced article. Contributors' statements do not necessarily reflect the opinion of this website, other people, businesses, or other contributors.